Waltham Forest Echo

Waltham Forest Echo

Government to scrutinise plans to rebuild Edmonton Incinerator

Secretary of State Michael Gove called for the scrutiny due to lobbying from a local MP

Hero for Government to scrutinise plans to rebuild Edmonton Incinerator
Edmonton Incinerator (credit: James Cracknell)

Secretary of State Michael Gove has asked for the £1.2billion plan to rebuild the Edmonton Incinerator to be scrutinised following lobbying from a local MP.Secretary of State Michael Gove has asked for the £1.2billion plan to rebuild the Edmonton Incinerator to be scrutinised following lobbying from a local MP.

The North London Waste Authority (NLWA), which represents seven boroughs including Waltham Forest, approved plans to replace its current incinerator in December last year.The North London Waste Authority (NLWA), which represents seven boroughs including Waltham Forest, approved plans to replace its current incinerator in December last year.

The authority believes the new incinerator is needed to replace the ageing current plant, built in 1971, with a cleaner and safer 'energy recovery facility' that will produce heat for local homes.The authority believes the new incinerator is needed to replace the ageing current plant, built in 1971, with a cleaner and safer 'energy recovery facility' that will produce heat for local homes.

Following lobbying by Conservative Chingford MP Sir Iain Duncan Smith, who firmly opposes the project, the department for Levelling Up, Housing & Communities will now examine whether it is the “best value” option.Following lobbying by Conservative Chingford MP Sir Iain Duncan Smith, who firmly opposes the project, the department for Levelling Up, Housing & Communities will now examine whether it is the “best value” option.

This partly stems from the rise in the estimated price tag of the rebuild, from £500million in 2017 to £1.2bn in 2019.This partly stems from the rise in the estimated price tag of the rebuild, from £500million in 2017 to £1.2bn in 2019.

Concerns have also been raised around the authority's transparency, with part of the waste authority's work managed through its arms-length commercial operator London Energy Ltd.Concerns have also been raised around the authority's transparency, with part of the waste authority's work managed through its arms-length commercial operator London Energy Ltd.

A letter from Michael Gove, dated 29th April, said: “I have asked officials in the department to engage directly with NLWA and its external auditor Mazars to better understand the arrangements the authority has in place for decision making, including governance, scrutiny and external audit.A letter from Michael Gove, dated 29th April, said: “I have asked officials in the department to engage directly with NLWA and its external auditor Mazars to better understand the arrangements the authority has in place for decision making, including governance, scrutiny and external audit.

“Alongside this, I have asked that we ascertain how NLWA are managing and delivering the [project].“Alongside this, I have asked that we ascertain how NLWA are managing and delivering the [project].

“I expect my officials to make comparisons to other waste authorities and large capital projects to provide assurance the NLWA are meeting the standards we would expect across the sector.”“I expect my officials to make comparisons to other waste authorities and large capital projects to provide assurance the NLWA are meeting the standards we would expect across the sector.”

However, Gove added there is a “high bar and evidential basis” for his department to be able to intervene in the incinerator project.However, Gove added there is a “high bar and evidential basis” for his department to be able to intervene in the incinerator project.

In response, a North London Waste Authority spokesperson said it has provided “extensive information” to show how it has achieved best value for money since 2017.In response, a North London Waste Authority spokesperson said it has provided “extensive information” to show how it has achieved best value for money since 2017.

They added: “The overall budget was established in 2019 at £1.2 billion. NLWA regularly reports on the project’s delivery and costs: it is being managed within this budget.  They added: “The overall budget was established in 2019 at £1.2 billion. NLWA regularly reports on the project’s delivery and costs: it is being managed within this budget.  

“The analysis then and now is that the project provides excellent value for money to build world-class infrastructure to deal with the waste of two million residents. “The analysis then and now is that the project provides excellent value for money to build world-class infrastructure to deal with the waste of two million residents. 

“Not only would other options cost taxpayers millions of pounds extra every year but also would result in a far less positive outcome for the environment.  “Not only would other options cost taxpayers millions of pounds extra every year but also would result in a far less positive outcome for the environment.  

“The project includes London’s biggest investment in recycling facilities in decades as well as the UK’s safest and most technologically advanced Energy Recovery Facility to generate heat and power for local homes.”“The project includes London’s biggest investment in recycling facilities in decades as well as the UK’s safest and most technologically advanced Energy Recovery Facility to generate heat and power for local homes.”

Residents and local politicians who oppose the plan argue that North London, with its low recycling rates, should not build a new incinerator that needs at least 490,000 tonnes of waste a year to function - 100,000 tonnes less than less than the amount north London produced in 2020/21.Residents and local politicians who oppose the plan argue that North London, with its low recycling rates, should not build a new incinerator that needs at least 490,000 tonnes of waste a year to function - 100,000 tonnes less than less than the amount north London produced in 2020/21.

Figures published by the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs estimate that recycling in NLWA boroughs is no more than 25-33%, well below the national target of 50%.Figures published by the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs estimate that recycling in NLWA boroughs is no more than 25-33%, well below the national target of 50%.

However, NLWA modelling predicts that more waste incineration capacity will be needed even if household recycling rates increase.However, NLWA modelling predicts that more waste incineration capacity will be needed even if household recycling rates increase.