A couple fined for leaving their bins out has accused enforcement company 3GS of being ‘bullies’
By Josh Mellor, Local Democracy Reporter
A Walthamstow couple issued a £400 “fly-tipping” fine for putting their waste outside at the wrong time of day has accused enforcement company 3GS of being “bullies”.
Filmmaker Carla Grande and her partner John Rowe say Waltham Forest Council and its enforcement contractor sent them “round and round in circles” when they asked for their fine to be reviewed.
The couple put their bin bags out on the street below their flat in St James Street at the wrong time soon after they moved in, having accidentally consulted part of the council’s website which does not show specific collection times.
Speaking at a council climate change scrutiny committee on 27th March, Carla urged the council to make its “harsh rules” on collection times clearer and to review how 3GS deals with appeals.
She said: “I feel there is no clear way of appealing or representing when you’re issued a fine[…] 3GS are essentially carrying out a third-party process.
“They are bullies to put it simply, they tell you to go to the council and you go round and round in circles.”
Emails from 3GS, shared with the Local Democracy Reporting Service, show the enforcement company repeatedly demanding the £400 payment without showing evidence that it had reviewed the couple’s case.
After numerous emails to 3GS, the council, her local councillors and MP, Carla said the council has agreed to reduce the couple’s fine to £150, the amount issued for littering offences.
Eventually, an anonymous council officer admitted that this was because the couple’s bin bags were “intended to be collected” rather than deliberately fly-tipped.
Carla told the committee: “I would like justification as to why this is, I believe that it’s because I am not going to give up.
This story is published by Waltham Forest Echo, Waltham Forest's free monthly newspaper and free news website. We are a not-for-profit publication, published by a small social enterprise. We have no rich backers and rely on the support of our readers. Donate or become a supporter.
“If it’s a littering fine, it should be a littering fine from the start, not a fly-tipping fine for putting bags out, not after sending emails for two-and-a-half months thinking I’m going to court.”
Director of neighbourhoods Jarlath Griffin said it would be “really difficult” to specify waste collection times on each household’s portal on the council’s website.
He added: “There are about 72 clear-all routes in the borough where residents put their waste out, the service goes through and reminds properties through a range of means how to go about this.
“The system has been the same system for five to ten years now, we’ve never really changed it from Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays and we try to keep it the same as we go through the whole process.”
Contrary to Carla’s experience, Jarlath claimed that 3GS offers “a way” of challenging fines it issues on behalf of the council which is “managed carefully”.
The senior officer admitted the £400 fines for fly-tipping are “quite expensive” but did not address Carla’s call for the council to justify why it does not issue residents with £150 littering fines instead.
In January this year, Walthamstow MP Stella Creasy said her office had begun “monitoring the experiences” of residents trying to appeal fines after “regularly” receiving complaints.
Her team, who have not responded to requests for comment, advised residents to challenge the fine directly before approaching her for help.
Figures obtained by the Local Democracy Reporting Service under freedom of information laws show that, in 2022, 3GS and the council issued 4,751 fines for “litter-related offences”.
However, just over half of those fines have been paid, bringing in only £362,500 – a significant drop from the £1.2m made in 2021.
While 217 fines were cancelled by the council, each month an average of 100 fines issued by 3GS are taken to court.
The council claimed it does not record statistics showing the reason fines are cancelled.
No news is bad news
Independent news outlets like ours – reporting for the community without rich backers – are under threat of closure, turning British towns into news deserts.
The audiences they serve know less, understand less, and can do less.
If our coverage has helped you understand our community a little bit better, please consider supporting us with a monthly, yearly or one-off donation.
Choose the news. Don’t lose the news.
Monthly direct debit
Annual direct debit
£5 per month supporters get a digital copy of each month’s paper before anyone else, £10 per month supporters get a digital copy of each month’s paper before anyone else and a print copy posted to them each month. £50 annual supporters get a digital copy of each month's paper before anyone else.
More information on supporting us monthly or annually
More Information about donations
